Simple Pure Soap
63 reviews
We have used SIMPLE SOAP for many years without any problems - but something bad has happened with the formulation as the soap smells different, and worst of all when left on the wash basin soap dish or in the shower it turns to very slippery mush. This mush has to be cleaned off the bar every time we use it meaning that we sluice off a total… Read more
amount of approximately 30% of each bar which is totally unacceptable in hassle terms and monetary terms as the bars last a much shorter time. The product development & marketing team who approved the change should hang their heads in shame and consider resigning - unless the product reverts to the original formulation which was perfect.
Probably stop using it now after 20 plus years – Being using this soap for years, i'm 70 now, but it now leaves a scum of some sort afterwards in the shower, which is very hard to get rid of. I don't know what the manufacturers have done, as it was great soap before.
Not Simple anymore – Have been using Simple soap for 38 years since recommended and loved the gentle formula, never used any other. What have you done to it??!! Trying to use cheap ingredients? Is it made somewhere else now? It smells awful-like chemicals and is drying. I will be buying another brand now , end of an era for us, you’ve lost us. Terrible Show details
Reviews with attachments
Double the price reduced size – Only 1 star because I can’t do zero ..charge double and reduced size .. Shame on you morons
Disgusting new recipe – The shape, size, colour and smell of bar have all changed and no notification on packet re this. I can’t even donate the bars they are so grim. I saw others saying it smells like sheep fat - but I agree it’s a horrible smell. Previously it was a gentle scent that was fresh and clean smelling like nice laundry smell. Now it’s like if you left… Read more
bacon fat to congeal on the side feels gross and waxy, I don’t feel it smell clean. I struggle to find safe products due to allergies and I’m heartbroken that they’ve wrecked one of my few pleasures, charged me money for it. Im gonna see if I can return to store as faulty from the smell alone and advise others to do the same - only by having lack of sales and refunds the company may start paying attention. Im guessing they sold out to another usa company where people accept this level of tripe claiming to be quality products. And a third of the bar is missing it’s a grim factory white colour not cream coloured. It’s like they started using an acme factory version - so much so I checked as I thought they were fakes. So disappointed - lost another customer (bought in Uk so assuming they’ve done this crap internationally)
I hate it now – It took me a while to find a soap with no perfume and yet still feels good when you use it. I have been using it for years now and even started using it for my toddler. All of a sudden is like the shower gel is different and the smell is so strong almost like a strong harsh smell. I thought it was fake but after reading all the reviews I find is… Read more
not and that they have changed it’s ingredient. I’m so so disappointed and dissatisfied. I purchased mines at super drug and the worst part was I purchased a lot due to it being on offer. I’m so so upset .
Latest follow-ups
Stopped using Simple soap because… – I have used Simple soap for many years. The new formula irritates my skin so much that I have had to stop using it altogether. I am so disappointed. Show details
Follow-up · I’ve gone back to Simple soap. It is still the best for my skin now I’m used to it.
EVERYTHING about the new soap is nasty – I have used simple soap for over since i was a teenager in the 80's. I have never used another soap but, I do not use simple soap anymore The change in formula, shrinkflation AND the MASSIVE price increase means I will never use it again. Its… Read more
pretty poor form to ruin a very good product. It was always $1.99 for two bars at chemist warehouse, now its over $6 for 2 bars IN BULK (48 bars) sand they are much lighter. I wont even bore you with the smaller purchase amounts priced because they are scandalous.
Thankfully i found dove extra sensitive soap to be a good substitution, it goes a bit quicker but it gives me no irritation, and that's the important part
Goodbye simple soap.
Follow-up · The new size is 50g smaller I used to get the old ones for $1.99 au for a 2 pack, now it's 24 packets for $140 at its cheapest They have changed to some sticky yellow substance that does not work or feel like the old one
Recent reviews
Contrary to popular opinion – I have been using this 'new' Simple soap for a few months now, having used the 'old' for 25 years. Yes, it is smaller, but I find it lathers much better, & I've never had a bar break in 2. (what are you guys doing with your soap?!) And, it no longer contains rendered down animal fat. Vegetable only. So, whilst obviously in the minority, I like it! Show details
Terrible goes to mush – Been using simple soap for years don’t know what’s been changed besides the shape but it goes to mush after a couple of uses will be looking for a new soap as it’s terrible now. Show details
Why change a good product? – I’ve bought this previously excellent soap for years, but the recent changes are not to my, or my family’s liking. The shape change to disguise a reduction in bar size is underhand, unnecessary and frankly unimportant. However the formula change is VERY important. After a few days use the bar turns into a soft ‘mush’ and becomes unpleasant to use, I will not be buying again
Horrible!! – The new soap dries my skin. It is difficult to get sudds from the soap. I now have to look for an alternative soap. I have used Simple soap for over 10 years. Lost a loyal customer. Show details
WHAT HAVE YOU DONE? – After using Simple Soap for years and years I have bought my last pack of 4 last week. Soap itself seems okay but the feel of being ripped off as I use it due to the drop in size and shape change is OVERPOWERING! Poor judgement right there Simple Soap!! Show details
Find out how Simple Pure Soap compares to other Hand Washes & Soaps
Know better, choose better.
Absolutely awful – In 18 years of using this product I’ve found the new formula to cause skin irritation and serious flare up of excema.. the shower gels are just the same… will never buy this product again. Show details
Disgusting – Have used Simple soap for I don't know how long. Just opened up a pack and what a horrid change to it, don't like the shape, the smell, its not the same anymore. As for changing the size of the soap into a silly shape is even more disgusting. Do your selves a favour to your loyal customers and put it back to it was, if its not broken why fix it? Not I'm looking for an alternative soap to use. You've made a bad mistake.
Awful changes – The new shape is dreadful. The new smell is nasty and the lather is poor. I have a very sensative skin and have used Simple products for more years than I care to remember, but this particular product will not be making an appearance in my shopping basket again. Show details
Don't buy the new soap (100g/3.5oz) – I've been using Simple soap for nearly 25 years, but I found the new-to-me changes unacceptable. They told me they changed it in March 2022, but the new product is only recently in my local store. I find the new smell disgusting, I hate that it now creates a horrid scum in my shower filter, I don’t like the smaller size, I don’t like the new… Read more
curved shape, and I don’t like that it now runs out much more quickly. I've been in touch with their customer relations, and the only point of my review on which they commented was about the new shape, which they say is better. I've found a suitable non-perfumed alternative (sorry, I can't advertise here), and will not be buying Simple soap again. I'm not surprised that two well-known UK chemists are no longer showing it on their websites.
Please bring original Simple Soap formula back – I was mortified to buy a 4 pack of my favourite soap (Simple) then unwrapped it and discovered the new formula, it's horrible and I won't buy it again. I agree with the other reviews - it definately feels and smells like sheep fat, I have used the original Simple soaps for 20+ years, the original bars had a lovely gentle and lasting fragrance that was great but this, ugh, they have lost me as a customer, I'm looking for an alternative soap now.
Unbelievably awful changes – Surprised by different size and shape. Couldn't trust my impressions of grey colour, vile smell and slimy feel. Then found these reviews. I won't even use it up. What stupid children were put in charge to do this? UK review. Show details
Why the change? – I can only assume that the reduction in size of the bar by 20% was a way to stay profitable. Many manufacturers have made their products smaller although not by quite as much as Pure have. If the product had stayed the same apart from the size there may have been far fewer poor reviews here, but with the reduction in size combined with what is… Read more
ostensibly an entirely different soap, the only constant thing is the wrapper. The soap has become slimy, difficult to rinse off, is used up much more quickly than it’s predecessor and tends to break in two. Pure must be depending on customer loyalty, but after 10 or so years of use, they have lost mine.
Strange shape! – I've noticed that the formula for the soap has changed & it now produces more foam, but the main disappointment for me is the change in shape of the bar. It is now difficult to turn it in your hands & breaks in half fairly soon after you first start to use the bar. Why change it? Show details
How to Destroy a Brand – I’ve used Simple soap for + 20 years but as they’ve now changed it’s formula, reduced is size and increase it’s price! I won’t be purchasing it anyone longer. Show details
Find out how Simple Pure Soap compares to other Hand Washes & Soaps
Know better, choose better.
The formula has changed! – Previously: Sodium Tallowate, Sodium Cocoate, Aqua, Sodium Palm Kernelate, Sodium Chloride, Glycerin, Tetrasodium EDTA, Etidronic Acid Now: Sodium Palmate, Sodium Palm Kernelate, Aqua, Glycerine, Palm Kernel Acid, Sodium Chloride, Tetrasodium Etidronate, Tetrasodium EDTA The new soap smells and creates an allergic respiratory reaction. Why, why,… Read more
why, do companies change hypoallergenic formulations that people seek out and come to depend upon, and screw things up for us?
The formula continues to change, however I've returned to using this soap. The new formula contains… Read more
Ingredient change – I have used this soap for years. It is the only one that doesn't irritate my skin or make it sore. The latest batch I bought looks different and I can no longer use it. My skin itches- just as with other soaps. I won't be using it any more. Show details
Italian brand made in Turkey – German based Lornamead was taken over by Italian brand Sodalis in 2021 and has gone down hill since. Final straw is the recent price increase of 20% due to shrinkflation. Show details
Not at all Simple – The return of Simple soap is such a disappointment. The new product is nothing like the soap we knew and used exclusively. It is slimey and smells. The new shape, with a 'squashed' centre combined with the squelshy texture has resulted in the bar breaking in two when about half used. I won't be buying it again. Show details
Simple soap used to be fantastic but it’s now rubbish – Straightaway I noticed the packaging had changed and the new Simple Soap is white whereas the original version was cream. It smells horrible, looks cheap and the underside is indented ie the soap has been made smaller from underneath in the hope customers won’t notice. It is now made in Turkey. I won’t buy it again.I’ll stick to Dove or Coop soap in future. Show details
Why change ingredients?? – Been a fan of the product for years, but have noticed a definite change! Bar lasts a fraction of the time to previous, it practically dissolves on contact with water! Very disappointed! And will find alternative asap Show details
Not what it was – The formula of Simple soap had definitely changed. The colour of the bar is different, it now appears to have a perfume, in spite of being described as "unfragranced" and finally, it doesn't lather up nearly as well as it used to. I shall gave looking for an alternative product. Very disappointed. Show details
Cheap and nasty soap – The new formula Simple soap will lose customers. It looks and feels cheap and nasty and negates my original reason for buying and using Simple soap. Slimy white deposits on my skin is not what I want. Along with other review authors I have ditched Simple soap. Show details
itching all over – Something in this soap is making me itch all over, have they changed an ingrediant or have they gone for cheaper ingrediants, something has changed. I have a home in Spain and have a cuboard full of simple soap that doesn't make me itch....Something has changed. Show details
The old formula is fine why change it please think about what we are saying – The new simple soap is smelly please go back to the old formula please please please or will not use any more Show details
It's horrible – The new Simple Soap is drying, like all other soaps. SO, SO, SO disappointed. I have used it for years and always before been very happy. I don't like it, will have to find a better soap now.
Used for 40 years – I have very sensitive skin and suffered acne as a lad. I found simple soap was the only soap that didn't agitate my skin. The good thing about this soap is that you can use it with a razor and lather it up with a shaving brush. You will need nothing else if you have this soap. I am 61 now and people cannot believe that's how old I am. I definitely put it down to using simple soap.
This is great for sensitive skin – Have not been able to buy this product in a long time. Great to see it available at Chemist Warehouse once again. . A great soap for sensitve skin problems
Extra Information
ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.
Mea culpa! Being too mean to throw away a load of bars of the soap I used it off and on, and have… Read more