456 reviews
would strongly caution anyone considering renting through this agency. During my tenancy, multiple repair and maintenance requests were either ignored or not actioned within a reasonable timeframe. I was ultimately forced to cover essential repairs out of pocket, including locksmith services, after being unable to get assistance. There was also… Read more
a prolonged loss of access to an allocated car space for approximately three months, with no compensation or meaningful resolution offered.
At the end of the tenancy, I was presented with claims that appear to go beyond fair wear and tear and do not adequately account for depreciation.
Overall, my experience was that tenant concerns were not taken seriously, and basic obligations around property maintenance and communication were not consistently met. I would recommend exercising caution.
I was renting with Ironfish. The rental agent was direct and professional. I can say the relationship was not overtly friendly, not rude at all, just transactional and formal. I have no problem with that. So I would give it a 3.5 stars. But when it was time to return the keys to the office, that was another story. Ironfish had just moved office to… Read more
Elizabeth street. My wife was going to the city to return the keys but she could not find the office. I called reception to ask them for direction. This guy just could not tell me. I asked him 4-5 times and he was sort of typing still along the way. In the end I had a meeting and needed to cut the conversation. My wife had to ask people on the streets. Once she found it, they made her wait 20 minutes or so just to return some keys. A simple common task has been made into such an unpleasant experience that I would give it a zero. In combining the 2 results, that would averaged a 1.75 star... so a 2 for me.
Dear Alxder, We are sorry to hear… Read more
Be very careful is you are leasing (tenant) with this agent (Carol - Ironfish) – We rented an apartment for our daughter in Melbourne - the agent (Carol) handled the exit of the lease was terrible. She bullied her way through and initially refused to return the bond. Communicated very abruptly and rudely (just to say the least). Please ensure if you are leasing with her / the company that you have a very detail Condition… Read more
Report before moving into the property else you stand a very good chance of being charged excessively and be bullied into potentially repainting the whole property just to satisfy her alleged claims. I will not trust, nor will I ever use this agent / company again. Not trustworthy.
Reviews with attachments
Terrible - Refused to clean feces – I had applied for a property without inspecting due to COVID restrictions. I was only able to inspect the property today, and noticed insects, leftover personal property and worst of all, urine and feces in the en-suite toilet. I requested that these be cleaned prior to me moving in, per tenancy law, and was told firstly, that cleaning could not… Read more
be arranged due to COVID restrictions. I spoke with DHHS who informed me this was incorrect, which I conveyed to Ironfish. Ironfish then told me that they do not want to pay for cleaning as it is not a serious issue. I explained that un-flushed feces, especially during a pandemic, is a serious cleaning issue - to which I was told I can just flush the toilet myself and this is not a serious cleaning concern. Incredibly disrespectful, immature and awful response to a reasonable request.
EDIT - I received a phone call from the team leader apologising for the agent’s conduct which I appreciated. The agent in question was quite junior and new to the role, however I do want to keep this review up as it was my genuine experience with the company. The team leader did offer to rectify the situation and have the property cleaned prior to occupancy however the experience unfortunately put a dark shadow over the property for me and I no longer wished to proceed with the tenancy.
In-depth reviews
Jie Zheng - Best Melbourne Property manager I’ve seen! – My two positive experiences with Jie are as follows: Towards the end of my lease I needed to extend my move out date by a few days. Jie was very helpful and liaised with the owner for me, despite it being short notice (3 days before the move date) and the opposite of what the landlord wanted. After I had moved out, the landlord queried problems… Read more · 1
in the apartment which has been there before my time or had been noted to the land lord but not yet fixed. I was informed that landlord expected to unfairly take the cost to resolve the issues out of my bond. Upon hearing of this, I called Iron Fish and spoke with Jie, who listened to me with patience and empathy while I proceeded to list every reason why this was unjust and not always in a calm tone. Jie asked me to email my evidence and said she would do what she could. Rarely do Property Managers seem to keep there word, but Jie called me thee days later to confirm she had campaigned on my behalf and that I would receive my bond back in full.
Thank you Jie Zheng for your patience, professionalism and integrity :)
first rental apartment – I met Spencer on my second day to Australia and he gave me many helpful tips on how to be successful in applying for apartments, as I have never rented through an agent before. Then once the application went through successfully, Spencer has been very helpful in answering all my questions with regards to moving in and the utilities. Not to mention… Read more
that the apartment is stunning with excellent facilities itself, at a reasonable rental price.
November 13th 2019 Update: Helpful assistance
Spencer Ling has been very helpful when I first arrived in Australia and was looking for a place to rent. He was very patient and gave me lots of advice on the application process and within a week of arriving in a new country I got into my dream apartment! A year later I brought my own house and moved out. On the last day of the lease I had a lot of trouble with the cleaners who increased their prices multiple times, asked for cash payments and didnt want to provide invoice, when we refused to pay them the inflated price (way above market price) the cleaners harassed me constantly with phone calls, text messages and threatened to take my bond (even though they had no access to the bond). I told Spencer what happened and he immediately empathised with me and took care of the situation by communicating with the cleaners directly. In the end I paid the cleaners their initial qouted price (still a very fair market price, if not more) and got my full bond back. So thanks to Spencer for looking out for me!
this realestate agency is sketchy af!! – there are several things that are wrong about this agency. First, our rent is charged 5 days earlier every month because they are using some nonsense third party payment thing that apparently charges people 5 days early without letting us know when we signed up the lease, we only found out when we got charged 5 days early and had to question the… Read more
agency! Secondly, we sent back the conditional report via email but they said they would consider it as we accepted their conditional report because they want a physical copy within 3 days... Thirdly, we had to pay for NBN connection fee ($300) ourselves, and NBN is the only option for us in the area, but the agent said, Internet is optional so they dont cover the connection fee. ????? Internet is optional????? it's 2018, come on! there are so many other things about this agency that just screams sketchy to us, like they would randomly cancel our sign-lease appointment just because they got a meeting ??? if you ever rent a property from this agency, give it a read on the contract, there are several rules that make us feel uncomfortable but they refuse to modify it because they said "we arent allowed to change the contract, but i can orally promise you this wouldnt happen".. so please please be careful if you are with this agency and please avoid them if you are looking for a place to rent.
Hi Blair, Thank you for reaching… Read more
Positive reviews
Best team – Thanks ironfish and thank a lot for carol she was very professional and quick respond Show reply
Best Agency in Melbourne – I have been renting with Iron Fish for at least 5 years now have to say they are the best so far. Fast response, efficient communication and amazing service as always. I will always recommend Iron Fish to my family and friends. Show reply
Highly recommend Coral! – Coral was a super friendly and incredibly helpful real estate agent! Took care of the apartment and was very quick to respond to any queries. Show reply
Negative reviews
Terrible property agent – We stayed at 105 Batman Street, West Melbourne, managed by Ironfish and agent Coral. Coral was one of the worst proeprty agents that my wife and I have had to date and we had a terrible experience. She was very difficult to contact and would often not be available for urgent requests. She was never pro-active with communication regarding end of… Read more
elase or contract negotiations. Her first response was always no, and she was very obstructive in our requests. She would not do her due diligence with laising with the propertty owner for discussions. We often had to escalate these conversations, onyl to find out the owner was more than happy to work with us. At end of lease, she did not do her duty and complete a considered end of lease inspection, leading to delay in getitng our bond.
Wouldn’t rent from them again. Zero values – 2 stars as the move in process was good. But wouldn’t rent from them again due to the move out process. Whoever completed the final inspection report obviously had no oversight of any previous reports, circling things that existed before I moved in that weren’t fixed before (and on top of this there was regular inspections/reporting of these… Read more
things during all my 3 years) Bad communication from the last agent: lacked any helpful information, courtesy, and dismissive on concerns. Leaving an impression the focus was purely on how much money they could squeeze from you at the end. It reminds me of that time they sent out the newsletter to everyone boasting all the excessive rent increases they achieved for landlords! They obviously forgot a lot of tenants helped fill their apartments when there was a massive oversupply during the pandemic! It would pay to treat them better, even in these times. Lastly if the company cleaner has to communicate on behalf of the agent re: bond/costs, then you’ve probably hired the wrong property manager.
Find out how Ironfish Real Estate Melbourne compares to other Real Estate Agents
Know better, choose better.
NRAS & Rental Rewards System sucks – I helped a friend get into an NRAS apartment. She has found that Ironfish have been really unhelpful if not rude. Imposing a weird "rental reward scheme that gives her no control. Being on Centrelink (mainly) she would ideally initiate a transfer of a half month's rent every Centrelink Payday (or have Centrelink do it as they do for commission… Read more
housing), but instead, the rent due 30th month seems to be required to be paid 9 days earlier ... and she has to manage a second account to make sure it's all funded .. It causes problems every month, and the agent's representative, who has proven unfriendly and unhelpful, refuses to reply to her callss and emails. She's being treated like scum. So NO!! Ironfish needs to lift it's game even if the system sucks!!
Hi Cliff, thank you for passing on… Read more
Recent reviews
Best real estate agent I've ever met – I have such a great experience with Ironfish and my property manager Coral Xiao. It's my 3.5 years with them. I especially thank Coral for her excellent communication and her sense of responsibility. Coral is so kind and responsive to any problems I've had when renting, such as how to make change to current tenant, or urgent repairs. She even… Read more · 1
helps when my current landlord is no longer able to rent the place to me. Given such a great experience with them, I decide to continue renting a new place with them :)
Great experience – Coral has been a great property manager for the past 4 years, she is always responsive whenever i had to contact her, never had issue with the rental, Good luck Coral Show reply
High level and professional agent- Coral – Coral is an amazing agent I’ve never met! She has been my agent for 4 years until now. She is very professional, she always gives me very helpful advices and suggestions. She is kind, patient and supportive. Even sometimes the issue is complicated, we have to make a lot of phone calls to communicate. She’s been there for me nicely and… Read more · 1
friendly. It really helps me that i can make a good decision quickly and solve the problems. Such an incredible agent!
I trust Ironfish very much through Coral!
All thanks to Coral!
Good experience – During my stay at MV, Coral was my agent. She was always very quick to respond to my queries and was also very direct. Appreciate her hardwork and professionalism. Show reply
Many Thanks to Coral – Coral has served as my agent manager for approximately six months. I am deeply grateful to her for facilitating the lease transfer, promptly addressing my inquiries via email, and conducting property issue checks with unwavering patience in person. Show reply
Amazing Experience – Renting with Iron Fish has been a total breeze, and I've got Coral to thank for that. Always there when you need her, super quick to sort out maintenance stuff or answer my questions. It's been such a smooth ride living here, all thanks to Coral's top-notch help and friendly approach. Show reply
Great service!! – Coral has been a great agent and so helpful. She has always responded my queries and helped me with my requests. I have been renting with Ironfish for almost 4 years now and would recommend them for anyone looking for rental properties. Show reply
Review – Kelvin has been most helpful. Whenever I have a something that needs fixing he is prompt to send a tradie to fix it. Kelvin has given me a great experience with Ironfish. Show reply
Find out how Ironfish Real Estate Melbourne compares to other Real Estate Agents
Know better, choose better.
Good place to live – Coral was our property manager for roughly 1,5 years. She was always a very professional and very helpful property manager who was available whenever we needed help. Show reply
Iron fish - Thanks to Coral – Coral by agent has been very kind and responsive. She understands the need to a Tenant and interacting with her has been very helpful.Thanks Coral. Show reply
High level and professional rental Agency – Agent is professional to handle our problem and question. They’re always there for us which we felt they’re the most helpful rental agency for so far until now. Show reply
Incredible service – Coral Xiao is my bm and she is very helpful to support my living experience. She always reply to my emails very soon and answers my questions patiently. Very impressive service! Show reply
Coral is the best – Coral has always been there for me. I never felt that it was this easy to lease an apartment but my agent coral made my life easy. I never faced any issues in the whole leasing process. Thanks for everything Coral ❤️ Show reply
Easiest Agency to deal with – Coral Xiao was the easiest agent to communicate with, we had no issues at all and would highly recommend IronFish Realestate to anyone. Show reply
Professional property managers – Coral is a very professional and very helpful property manager who is available whenever need help. She is very responsive. She was my property manager for close to 2 years. Ironfish manage the properties very well. The Melbourne Village in west Melbourne is awesome place to stay . Clean and very organised. Should thank Ryan as well before covid he was my property manager and helped to fix issues as soon as reported. Thanks to Ironfish team! Show reply
Outstanding service – Coral Xiao, property manager, is just amazing! She helped me all the way during my stay with Ironfish and also after, when I was looking for a new place to live. Great communication, always providing solutions and very friendly. Show reply
Extra Information
ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.
Dear Jessica, Thank you for your… Read more