3,353 reviews
AI reviews summary
The overall sentiment for Compare The Market is highly positive, with most users reporting significant financial savings on car, health, and home insurance. Customers frequently praise the professional and patient phone support provided by consultants who help navigate complex policy details. However, a segment of users reports frustration with aggressive follow-up tactics and discrepancies between initial online quotes and final prices.
Pros
Cons
Verdict
Compare The Market is an effective tool for consumers looking to reduce premiums and simplify the insurance research process, particularly through its highly-rated telephone consultancy. While the service offers genuine savings, users should be prepared for immediate sales calls and potential price variations between the initial estimate and the final binding quote.
I received a quick and pleasant surprise from this ‘Comparison’ website, I’m very happy with the insurance cover, it was quick and easy to except the offer for my contents cover.
Was confused with private health insurance for many years. Finally took a callback from FRANCESCO who spent over an hour with me on the phone and explained every question I had and the complex nature of private health. I walked away with a great understanding he called back as requested at a later date and I signed up. Could not be happier with this blokes help he went above and beyond! Asset to your company
Felt not really advised about different options. Operator first felt friendly then got super pushy. I think I will cancel the service again. Got up sold, not really what I wanted but more
Reviews with attachments
The travel insurance options were easy to find and compare. Show reply
Takes the pain out of comparing – Very easy to use and certainly saved me money. Much easier than having to phone round all the companies and compare myself.
Possums don't lie – Got insurance for my new car. Took a few minutes and easily the best price doing it that way. Meekets are awesome. Will definitely use this again for my bike.
This is just a scam comparison website to plug Budget Direct. They will offer you a price on Budget Direct that owns compare the market as if it’s the best company but if you read it closely it includes 15% off new customer deal so next year insurance goes up 15%. They are only comparing a select few insurance companies to make Budget Direct stand… Read more
out. They will also start ringing your mobile even if you just want to browse it’s very annoying. Better off doing your own research on reputable insurance companies websites.
Hi Daniel, Thank you for your review. We aim… Read more
I clicked the result from a Google search – Oops, I clicked the link from a Google search for car insurance. Now I see it is that animated animal on TV commercials. Normally I would not select this company because the commercials are too silly to watch. I filled in the phishing form and received some overpriced offers. I selected contact via email, but those emailed offers should also… Read more
provide an option to cancel and delete my contact information since they were unsuitable.
I have received several phone calls from an automated call centre robot that connects me to another person who wants my info, I reluctantly give it to try and have my phone number removed from their lists.
Second day receiving calls, so I have blocked the number.
UPDATE: after compare the market, I checked the options and they were all more expensive than AAMI, so I didn't use anything from compare the market. The sharing information with their partners must be responsible for the sudden increase in spam messages requesting me to click the attached links. Image attached as evidence.
Latest follow-ups
Was very helpful in locating more economical gas and electricity provider. Show reply
Follow-up · Approximately 10-12 Very easy No Compare the market only Very happy with new provider’s - definitely saving money.
Was an extremely fast process that took $450 off our annual insurance review.
Follow-up · Based on the information provided, we chose budget direct. Just be mindful, renewals will be automatic 12 months later with this insurance company so keep a date in your diary two weeks prior to go through the process of compare the market again to ensure the rate is still competitive.
Best price on car insurance . A considerable saving on the most advertised…. Show reply
Follow-up · Range from $1300 to $2130 ….. Easy process , especially for an old timer …. There was no hidden fees ….MG 3 motor vehicle, 2023 model .
In-depth reviews
Lachlan P from comparethemarket (health insurance) is without a doubt the best telemarketer I've ever had an interaction with in my life hands down (I could go on and have to others elsewhere haha). If I was in the business for such an employment position needing to be filled, Lachlan P would be my first choice. I would've offered him a job if i… Read more · 1
could have!
Like anyone these days, a call from an unsaved number cues an immediate resistance to engage in the conversation even if you consented to being called... Why, because more often than not I (like most people) end a call like that either feeling pushed for a sale, or as though the caller was impersonal throughout the process. Alas! Lachlan P enters the scene... My partners phone rings within moments of her entering our details into compare the market. Flabbergasted, by the time from which details were entered and the call came through to her, shock initially lead the exchange. Unbeknown to Lachlan, the call was on speaker and I initially sat in my usual response to the given situation (here we go again... [eye roll and sigh]). My habitual response to the situation was extinguished almost immediately because my partner and I were taken through the process without any hesitation on our end. For the first time ever my only concern was that I wanted to give some telemarketer my money. WTH?!?
Whilst I would presume trained to some the necessary extent... Lachlan P has something I believe most people aren't taught by such a job position, maybe at best encouraged... The perfect amount of personability and what genuinely felt to be an authentic positive desire to help (most average telemarketers or sales representatives try, but people read between the lines if you get what I'm saying) . I only ever write reviews when I mean it and genuinely want to. Whoever Lachlan P's Managers are better be paying him more than any other telemarketers in the Industry I (and likely most others) come across because If Lachlan P wanted to, I reckon he could get paid a more than healthy sum working somewhere that genuinely values such an employee (if he is not already). Thanks for your help Lachlan P!!! PS, I do not have any reason to believe Comparethemarket do not look after Lachlan or there staff, all I'm saying is it would be within there best interst not to lose Lachlan P as an employee if its an option.
PPS, If somone at comaprethemarket is considering whether to promote Lachlan P, I believe you would be silly not to. Just saying.
Find out how Compare The Market compares to other Insurance Comparison Websites
Know better, choose better.
The old saying is if you can’t afford travel insurance then you shouldn’t travel. I hate paying travel insurance simply because I never make a claim. And I wouldn’t like to try either but it’s a necessary evil. Like all insurances, travel insurance is not cheap especially as you get older. Every time I travel I go online reluctantly looking for… Read more · 1
the best possible deal. They try and sell me everything when all I want is medical only. One company Zoom says they do not provide medical only for people my age even though I have no medical problems and I have never made a claim which must count for something but it doesn’t. Aren’t insurance premiums all about the risks and I’m not a risk. I tried Compare The Market which provided me with many companies who did medical travel insurance only and at a reasonable price too. Through them I was able get rid of all the extras which lowered my premium substantially. They gave me a great choice of insurance companies, so well done Compare The Market for making it a competitive market place and we all know competition is great for consumers.
Not a complaint about the company itself but a staff member named Anthony. I put my expression of interest online and received a phone call from Anthony. The reason I was looking into health insurance I have a new born baby and there is a possibility he would need a procedure done. I already had private health insurance but I was looking at other… Read more
alternatives to add my son on. Anthony tried to do his best to absorb his options with me but what he was offering wasn’t suitable for my needs I explained to him what was important to me and he advised that my sons future procedure wouldn’t be covered because it was within the waiting periods which I understood. I was looking for hospital and extras cover he went through a few options with HCF but I was quoted $260 and I explained it wasn’t affordable he then quoted $130 a fortnight however it wasn’t covering me for extras cover so I advised Anthony it wasn’t suitable for me and his tone completely changed and made a comment saying what’s more important to you having extras cover or your son. I was made to feel like a bad mother and he started to patronise me it got to the point he was trying to pressure sell to me and he was just desperate for a sale. I put a complaint forward to customer resolutions team and I got a lovely manager named Karina who had listened to the call and was very disgusted with what she heard on the phone. Karina was very apologetic and had escalated things with Anthony’s direct manager. The reason I am writing this review is to raise awareness for those who are in a vulnerable position needing some help with looking at health insurance. Anthony doesn’t care about you as an individual like what he says he wants to do he is just after your sale. Thank you Karina for your help you have heard my concerns with the comment that was made to me and how he made me feel.
Positive reviews
2nd time user with Compare the Market and one who is a little hesitant and unfamiliar with online stuff .... Wow, the ease in getting results to help in the anxious negotiating with my insurers because of what Compare The Market showed me was amazing. Saved nearly $500 over the year on my car insurance. Show reply
We had been with our current insurer for the past 27 years. Our home and contents insurance had escalated to the stage where we could not afford the full cover offered - including flood insurance. We sought to delete the flood insurance and our current insurer was still way more costly. We went with an insurer who currently had our care insurance - this saved us over $800. Show reply
I compared and received multiple results that were cheaper than my existing insurer. My only issue was that the results didn't work well with my browsers of choice – Safari and Firefox. I couldn't just click forward on the options to see the PDS. The work around was to do comparison, check out the PDS, and then click forward. Show reply
Negative reviews
They dont compare the Market, it is really misleading, they only compare Auto and General policies. I got results from ING, Coles, Budget, Oceania and Ozicare, all of which are under written by Auto and General. Insurers not with Auto and General "Could not provide a quote" and they were AHM and Some other brand. None of the Auto and General… Read more
brands offer low excess/no excess windscreen cover as standard. When selecting the low excess option, it adds $20 on average per month to the cover. Whats the point then if that is the case?
Hi Izak, thanks for taking the time to share… Read more
I chose this comparison service to find a better deal on comprehensive car insurance. After answering all the initial online questions truthfully, it gave me a range of quotes. I selected what I thought was the most appropriate and cost effective at $635. After selecting that provider and completing the process online, the final price for 12… Read more
months was $917. I find this to be very misleading and deceptive, and a complete waste of time. Not recommended.
Hi there, thank you for your review. All… Read more
Quoted $4148 for home and contents insurance, when I selected the option the final quote without making any changes increased to$5401. I was told by the insurer that this is common. What a waste of time.
Hi Troy, thank you for your review. All quotes… Read more
Recent reviews
Was directed through my choices with easy language and not rushed by person on the other end. Not being techno saffy I find filling in sections quite daunting so I really appreciated having someone assist me in applying Show reply
Find out how Compare The Market compares to other Insurance Comparison Websites
Know better, choose better.
Easy to navigate, great to compare options. The only thing I’d have appreciated would be more filter options when comparing, as there were specific policy covers I was weighing up and had to click in to each (or 3 at a time when comparing) to figure out ones that had the cover I needed. Show reply
I just thought I'd give it a try on my latest house insurance renewal and the result was amazing. Not only did I save nearly $1000 on my policy but it was so much easier to use than the insurance company's own website. Show reply
Sahra from Compare The Market went above and beyond with helping me choose the best private health care provider (I'm a 31-year-old signing up for the first time with no knowledge in this area) based off my personal circumstances. She listened attentively to my questions and circumstances, and I sincerely thought her thorough explanation and… Read more · 1
guidance was unbiased and suited to me as an individual. Everything was clear and made sense. The process was smooth and I couldn't imagine a better experience.
I started an application with compare the market for health insurance then was called directly by lovely man by the name of Dylan H The service provided was amazing & all the information I needed to know & access was very transparent & layed out in the simplest form for myself to understand Excellent service & if I know anyone who is in the market for health for insurance I will be highly recommending Dylan H for the service Thank you Show reply
Absolutely Fantastic, Dealt with Tiana, very helpful and knowledgeable, was very sympathetic to our needs and talked us through the whole process. Couldn't recommend highly enough.5 stars for knowledge, patience and courtesy, credit to the company. Belynda and Nick Brisbane Show reply
I was helped by Damon today he had exceptional patience and excellent customer service he helped me all the way along with my insurance quote and was able to provide me a better price. I wanted to personally thank Damon for his excellent service and taking the time to get me the best price and value for our car. Show reply
Excellent quick comparative/competitive quotes received to help us both times when renewing our car insurance this year. Very happy with the results helping us save costs in times like this. Show reply
I had a fantastic experience using Compare the Market to find car insurance. The process was quick, easy, and saved me a lot of time compared to searching through providers individually. What I appreciated most was being able to compare multiple quotes side by side, making it simple to find the best value for my needs and budget. Through Compare… Read more · 1
the Market, I was able to secure a great deal with Budget Direct that offered excellent coverage at a very competitive price.
The website was user-friendly, the information was clear and easy to understand, and the whole experience was hassle-free from start to finish. Thanks to Compare the Market, I felt confident that I was making an informed decision and getting the best possible deal.
I would highly recommend Compare the Market to anyone looking to save time and money when shopping for insurance. Finding a great policy with Budget Direct was easy, and I'm very happy with the outcome.
ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.
Hi Marie, thank you for taking the time to… Read more