2,916 reviews
AI reviews summary
Feedback for Sydney Tools indicates a significant divide between positive in-store interactions and a highly problematic corporate service model. While individual floor staff are frequently praised for their technical knowledge and helpfulness, the company faces severe criticism regarding its restrictive refund policies, stock management, and online order fulfilment.
Pros
Cons
Verdict
Sydney Tools is a viable option for in-person purchases where the buyer is certain of the exact product required and can verify stock and pricing on the spot. However, consumers should be extremely cautious regarding online orders and high-value items due to a rigid return policy that frequently conflicts with standard consumer expectations and reported difficulties in obtaining refunds for faulty or "not fit for purpose" goods.
Over the last 20 years I have bought from Sydney Tools. I always bought brand name machines and the team at Sydney Tools was great. This week, I bought a Daytona kit to remove ball joints and tie rid ends. Within 30 minutes of use, the tool failed and cracked. It is pretty obvious that the poor quality casting is not fit for purpose. I returned… Read more
it to the shop, and after waiting an hour, I was told that the tool had been abused. I wanted to return the kit for a refund or store credit, they refused. As a good-will offer, they replaced the broken items.
So I now have a kit that I know will break if it is used as "designed" and I understand that it isn't a good idea to buy the shop brand (Daytona), or to trust the warranty return process at Sydney Tools.
Charged $20.88 service fee for using Amex. There was a surcharge sticker on the device, but it was faded so badly that I couldn’t see it. I asked the assistant (John) before swiping if they accepted Amex, he could have warned me about the fee but chose not to. The assistant then went on to say that I could get the fee back by complaining to… Read more
Sydney Tools. I did this and got nothing. Greedy assistant just after the sale. I will not be shopping here again.
Good Afternoon, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more (+4 replies)
Reviews with attachments
Anthony was very knowledgeable and had the patience and time to direct me to the required isles for mechanical tools (considering I’m a plumber). Tools for Upper:Lower ball joint replacement Very helpful Thanks Show details · 1
Blake at Sydney Tools Tuggerah continues to impress - bought 2 Makita electric chainsaws Models UC4041A & DUC353PT2 for tree trimming and firewood processing. Very happy with the outcome.......also purchased a grease gun yesterday and a fuel tank for a GX390 engine today. Thank you, Blake for your product knowledge and customer service.......Ash Show details · 1
LOOK FOR MITCHELL OF SYDNEY TOOLS – I bought over $2000 of gardening tools from Sydney Tools Brookvale. They promptly replaced the lawnmower when I returned it unused, possibly damaged in shipping. Good Service. After I left the shop, and unpacked the unsealed replacement box, i found another part was missing- the blower extension. I made 3 phone calls, first 2 calls, received… Read more · 1
promises but no action. On my third call almost end of day, I spoke to Mitchell. He was very helpful - A legend. Mitchell called me within minutes when he found the missing part in their store. Sydney Tools could do very well with Mitchell' s attitude . Great service.
High Praise for a Job Well Done – I purchased a laser level from Zack at the Virginia store. Great guy very helpful, respectful, knowledgeable and honest. Needed a stand as well with the attachment to read the numbers in the daylight. Not only did he work through all the pros and cons of the different machines but found some that were on sale. We have used it numerous times and… Read more · 1
its a great product. Sydney tools is my go-to and looking forward to going back to purchase some more items for our construction business. Festool is my next brand to work towards !
Return of goods service – I made a mistake when ordering with incorrect model number, Toni was happy for me to return and get them replaced. Show details
Sure they have a no returns policy which i didnt realise. But $100 purchase same day return untouched goods without even offering credit just does not cut it as far as im concerned. Bunnings offer an excellent return policy, same goes for Tradetools never had issue with credit. I've burnt $100 on something i'll never use. I got a gratuitious reply… Read more
from rep along the line of, "..thanks for concern... well take it onboard..". Sorry I find it hard to believe you will, i've now read other comments online about people who have had a similar experience. Publishing.
Good Morning, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more
On Friday 13th March I received an SMS text from Sydney Tools advertising a weekend sale. One of the products advertised on their sale website was a Husqvarna 530iPT5 36V pole saw reduced by more than 50% (https://sydneytools.com.au/product/husqvarna-530ipt5-36v-liion-cordless-brushless-254mm-10-pole-saw-skin-only). The advert noted that it was in… Read more
store only so I I went to our local store to enquire if they had any in stock and was advised that these items were not sent into WA at all and that they were only stocked in small numbers at few shops. I was encourage to contact eastern states stores however I could only find two stores with any of the items and was advised that it would not be possible to ship these to WA. I was further advised that they were only advertised as part of the sale to clear a small qty of old stock. The web advertising did not make clear the fact that WA was excluded from this sale, nor that the company held almost no stock of the advertised product. This is a clear example of Bait Advertising.
On the 14th March I emailed Sydney Tools and explained the situation. They actually confirmed that they had very limited stock of the item with the reply:
"Good Afetrnoon, Thank you for your email. I sincerely apologise about this matter. I can confirm in the screenshot you have provided it does 'in store only', this is due to the limited amount of stock being available. I understand your frustration with this matter, and your feedback is greatly appreciated. I can advise you we have taken this feedback on, and will ensure this does not happen again."
I was curious to see if they would take any action, so, on the 19th March I checked their website and found the same advertised special, but could not find any store with stock.
I checked again on the 23rd March and the product is still advertised at the same price.
If Sydney Tools have old floor stock that they want to clear, it should not be included in a nationwide advertising campaign as part of a promotion because this is misleading. It should either be clearly disclosed on your website or it should not be included in the campaign. And if after a customer points out that their advertising is misleading and they do nothing about it then it is pretty clear that they dont care. Im pretty sure I wont buy from these scammers again.
Good Morning, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more
Be aware that Sydney Tools may display items in-store at prices lower than what they are actually willing to sell them for. I recently attempted to purchase a workbench that was clearly ticketed at $1,499 on the display item, with all details (including the model number) matching correctly. However, the sales assistant advised that the “correct”… Read more
price was $1,699, as listed on their website. While they acknowledged the ticket price was their mistake, they would not honour it—only suggesting they might “take a bit off” given the item was a scratched display model. Two days later, I returned to the same store and found the item still advertised at $1,499. On this occasion, the sales assistant consulted with the Area Manager, who declined to honour the displayed price. After leaving the store, I contacted Sydney Tools customer service. I was informed that their policy is to sell items at whatever price they scan at the register, and that signage to this effect is displayed in-store. However, I was also advised that, to comply with ACCC guidelines, if there is a discrepancy between the displayed price and the scanned/website price, the store should either honour the lower price or remove the item from sale until the issue is resolved. Based on my experience, this process was not followed at the Carrum Downs store. Overall, a disappointing experience and not what I would expect in terms of pricing transparency or customer service. On the up side - I have now found an equivalent items for sale at Bunnings at a lower price!
Good Morning, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more
I went with my son to the store at Hoopes crossing, and we were shocked by what happened. We saw an item clearly priced at $19, but at the counter, they charged us $38. When I questioned it, they refused to refund the money and wouldn’t even offer store credit. They told us we had to buy something immediately or get nothing. My son was so… Read more
disappointed, saying he didn’t expect this kind of behavior in Australia. It felt like they had no intention of fair service. This was a terrible experience for both of us.
Good Morning, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more (+2 replies)
Would give no stars of if I could. I bought gas torch online that was advertised as reaching 2400 degrees Celsius, I come to find out this was actually meant to be Fahrenheit. Tried to email them and all they did was immediately change their website description of the torch and proceed to ignore me. I rang about 3 times trying to talk to someone… Read more
and on the 3rd time got onto a very rude person who insisted I was wrong and that they couldn’t refund me just because there was a unit wrong on their website. I was told it was only $40 so to just deal with it. When I said I’m legally entitled to a refund they proceeded to say they didn’t agree with me. Will never shop here again and will be reporting to the ACCC.
Good Afternoon, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more
Find out how Sydney Tools compares to other Hardware Shops
Know better, choose better.
Latest follow-ups
Selling items they dont stock – They do not respond to my emails and are selling items they don't have in stock, I can not cancel the order and go 10 minutes up the road and buy directly from the store.
Follow-up · I brought a 8kv generator from them and its been fine. I was able to go in and pick it up the same day. Just will never order anything on line from them, it appears to be common with most tool suppliers they say things are in stock and never are.
Good Afternoon, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more
I’ve been a loyal customer of Sydney Tools for many years—long before Sydney Tools even opened stores in Adelaide. Whenever I needed tools, Sydney Tools was always my first choice. Even when prices were the same—or cheaper—elsewhere, I chose Sydney… Read more
Tools because of their service and price matching. However, I recently had a disappointing experience that’s made me reconsider my future purchases. On 18th June, I purchased a Festool FS WA from Sydney Tools. Unfortunately, the item didn’t fit with my system. I returned it in brand new, unused condition, hoping to make use of what I believed was a 14-day return policy for peace of mind—something I had previously seen on a laminated printed paper in the store. When I brought it back, the staff were helpful and processed a Festool 30-day money-back guarantee form. However, Festool rejected the form. I was then told that Sydney Tools had recently changed its return policy and that the 14-day change-of-mind return is no longer offered. When I bought the Festool item from Sydney Tools, I was not aware that the return would depend on whether Festool accepted it. I thought I was dealing with Sydney Tools—not Festool. Now I’m left wondering—if I buy other brands like Makita and DeWalt from Sydney Tools, are returns also subject to whether those companies say yes or no? If Sydney Tools are unable to control the return process, they should tell the customer at the time of purchase. I understand that staff were simply following the current policy. That said, I was disappointed to find that a policy I had relied on in good faith was quietly changed—especially when no clear notice of that change was given at the time of purchase. The lack of clear communication about the new return conditions and who actually decides on the return was incredibly frustrating. From now on, I’ll need to think more carefully before making future purchases at Sydney Tools. Retailers like Total Tools still offer a more flexible reliable return policy, including for used items that turn out not to be suitable. I hope Sydney Tools will consider reinstating a more customer-friendly return policy. It’s unfortunate to feel let down after many years of loyalty.
Final update:
Sydney Tools replied to my review with an apology and said they would take my feedback on board. However, when I replied again—directly asking whether I could return the item or what steps I could take—they never responded.
I have since checked their returns policy again, and it has now changed to a strict "No Returns" policy. According to their website, all sales are final, and they no longer accept returns, exchanges, or refunds unless required by law. Any returns now depend on warranty claims or manufacturer policies.
In comparison, Total Tools currently offers a 30-day change-of-mind policy for unused items in resaleable condition (with some exclusions).
Given this, I strongly recommend that anyone buying from Sydney Tools carefully review their return policy before purchasing—especially if you are used to more flexible policies elsewhere.
Final update part 2:
I contacted Festool directly and explained what happened. Festool themselves were surprised and even asked me, “Can they not even give you store credit?”
I also asked Festool whether I would have been able to return the item if I had bought it directly from the Festool website, and Festool confirmed yes, if I had purchased from the Festool website directly, I would have been able to return it.
Moving forward, I’ll be buying direct from the Festool website instead.
Follow-up · I bought it at the Sydney Tools Parafield, it not hard to return, but I can't return, I never used it, and I didn't take it out of the box
Good Afternoon, Thank you for your feedback. We… Read more (+7 replies)
Just to inform other customers that the refund and exchange policy is terrible. Please think many times before buying anything valuable as they refuse to refund or upgrade to something better after two weeks time. It’s not like other retailers.… Read more
Luckily, I bought a cheap tool bag and its retractable handle just jammed after few months and way before warranty expiry date. Initially, store manager sent an email to someone in the eastern state to get an approval to do anything further, and asked to revisit next week. Revisited and obviously, it was approved for exchange and asked them if we can get something better by paying the difference as the product wasn’t great and there are chances that it will break soon or later but store manager refused to do anything except to exchange the product. We went there twice and spent more on fuel by considering to buy something better,,ended up buying from another retailer. We decided not to buy anything from Sydney tools again.
Follow-up · No one contacted so far, as informed earlier, manager didn’t even bother to attend personally. Tool bag was just for daily use tools for IT related equipment repairs. To be honest, I am not thinking to buy anything from Sydney tools. There are so many other better options. I hate Sydney tools.
Good Afternoon, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more (+3 replies)
Positive reviews
I have purchased quite a few items from Sydney Tools Gregory Hills. Mo is the guy to see, he goes above and beyond to ensure customer satisfaction. He has spent so much time contacting suppliers to find me the correct items. I cannot speak highly enough of Mo, Sydney Tools is my first stop for all my equipment needs. Thanks Mo much appreciated. Show details · 1
Was very happy with Archerfield store and guys who helped me.I want to mention Anthony who found connection for my chicago compressor and hose I was looking for.He also helped to attach it.Would recommend the store and services. Show reply
Will and Bee were amazingly helpful and all with a smile! I’m really grateful because it can be intimidating for an older woman going into places like Sydney Tools but they made it so easy and even fun Show details · 1
Negative reviews
Be careful when you buy something from Sydney Tools and you would like to exchange it. They have a seemingly strict no returns policy for change of mind. Which now has influenced me to shop elsewhere.
Good Morning, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more
Purchased a ego lawn mower set from a promotion online on the 8th May. Received the order confirmation on the same day and later on another email saying that 2 items are out of stock. I have been trying to get an update, at least give me an ETA, for almost a month now. They dont' reply my email at all. When contacting the order@sydneytools.com.au… Read more
they ([Names Removed])give me the same reply. Thank you for your email. I can confirm that I have passed your inquiry onto our Forrestdale branch. They will contact you accordingly. If there's anything else I can assist you with, please let me know. When you try the live suport, [Names Removed] gave me the same reply and the live support even went offline when I asked to cancel my order and have a refund.
I have filed a dispute with Afterpay as I have no idea whether I will ever get the items I ordered. 3 mistakea made... 1. Not doing research of the merchant before placing an order. 2. Assuming I won't be able to place an order when the item is not in stock. 3. Using Afterpay as payment method. Lesson learnt.
Good Morning, Thank you for your feedback. We… Read more
Ripped off – I ordered a jack from these dodgy operators, After taking my money and postage charge 11/4/17 and after hearing nothing for two weeks i sent them an email asking "where is my jack Sydney tools", They sent me an email telling me that this jack was not in stock at the moment and I would have to wait until May. in the middle of May I sent another… Read more
email "where is my jack Sydney tools" and they responded that I would have to wait until the end of June. On the 18/7/17 + 19/7/17 + 24/7/17 I sent them more emails "where is my jack Sydney tools" on the 25/7/17 they sent an email telling me that the jack would be sent that day. on the 30/8/17 I sent them another email "where is my jack Sydney tools" On 1/9/17 I received an email saying they had dispatched my jack. 8/7/17 email from me threatening them with consumer affairs "where is my jack Sydney tools" They emailed me back "would you like a refund" . Well I figured that would be the only way I would get anything so I said yes. So they refunded the cost of the jack but not the shipping charges or an apology. I think I am lucky to receive anything . Good work Sydney Tools
Find out how Sydney Tools compares to other Hardware Shops
Know better, choose better.
Recent reviews
I had a great experience dealing with Anthony Masciocci. I originally had a different Milwaukee combo set in mind, but Anthony took the time to understand what I actually needed and recommended a much better-value option. Instead of just selling me the more expensive kit, he found a combo set that offered more tools and better overall value for… Read more
the money. His product knowledge, honesty, and willingness to help made the whole process easy and stress-free. I really appreciated that he focused on getting me the best deal rather than just making a sale.
Untrustworthy? I made an online order two weeks ago for PPE. It was allocated to South Nowra, which has done nothing to actually ship the order and has also not contacted me in any way. Sydney Tools central seems entirely ambivalent to the situation as well. So, if you like actually receiving your orders, perhaps try elsewhere?
Good Afternoon, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more
Very disappointing experience at Sydney Tools Gregory Hills. I went in to buy a Makita kit as a gift and made it clear that I did not really know tools and needed advice. I was helped by a salesperson who was actually very helpful. I was unsure which kit to buy, and I was told words to the effect that I could buy the first kit, go have lunch,… Read more
check with the person I was buying for, and come back shortly if I needed to upgrade. I came back around 10 to 15 minutes later and upgraded to the larger Makita kit, DK0141G302, which cost $1,448.10. The kit stayed unopened, sealed, unused and in the original packaging. Shortly after, I found out the person I was buying for only needed the drill, so I tried to return the whole unopened kit and buy the drill separately. I was not trying to keep part of the bundle. I wanted to return the full sealed kit and buy the correct item. In my view, the main issue was the way the store manager handled the situation. The salesperson who helped me was fine, but once the return issue came up, the store manager’s handling made everything much worse. The store manager refused to process a cash refund and I was told only store credit would be offered, even though I was trying to return the whole kit almost immediately and it was still completely unopened. I was also told words to the effect that refund requests had to be escalated to the state manager for approval. But when I followed up, the response I got was still basically store credit only. From my perspective, that was not fair or transparent, especially after I relied on what I was told in store. What made it even worse is that Sydney Tools later framed the store credit offer as them “meeting me halfway” and as a “gesture of goodwill,” saying they had already gone out of their way to swap my original purchase. That is not how I see it at all. I came back almost immediately, the item was unopened, and I was trying to resolve the issue properly. Offering store credit for a $1,448.10 unopened kit is not “meeting halfway” in my opinion. They also later claimed their returns policy was clearly displayed at eye level on the desk. That was not my experience. No returns policy was pointed out to me before I paid, and I dispute the way they have described what happened. I also contacted head office. The first phone call with head office was very disappointing. In my experience, they were rude, dismissive and not helpful. I have also tried emailing head office and the store multiple times, but the position remained the same: no proper refund, only store credit. I am now having to go to NSW Fair Trading and NCAT to submit a claim just to try to get my money back for an unopened item. In my opinion, this could have been handled with common sense and basic courtesy within five minutes. The Makita product itself is not the problem. The problem is the way the sale, upgrade and return request were handled, especially by the store manager, and then the lack of proper help from head office afterwards. Based on my experience, I would not recommend Sydney Tools Gregory Hills. If you need clear advice, transparent return information or fair after sales support, I would seriously consider saving your money and going elsewhere.
Good Morning, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more
To describe them as clowns is generous. I ordered a product. They said they could not get it in for a few weeks, and asked if I wished to proceed. I emailed to say I would cancel the order. They ignored my email, and eventually mailed me the product. Before it had reached me, I instructed Aus Post to return it to the Dulwich Hill store. That was… Read more
what Sydney Tools instructed me to do. For some reason, Aus Post could not find the store and sent it to the Dulwich Hill post office. And that is where it now sits. I gave Sydney Tools formal authority to collect it. Sydney Tools has made no effort to retrieve it. I have ordered a charge-back on my credit card. Avoid these guys.
Good Morning, Thank you for taking the time to… Read more
Best not to order online from these doofus's. They send orders to whatever store they think might have stock. If the store doesn't have stock , even though the website says they did, they will just sit on the order indefinitely and not contact you at all. Making you waste time and money chasing things that have had payment accepted. But no attempt at delivery. They are stuck in the stone age.
Good Afternoon, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more
If there was _ i would give minuse 10..we bought a item and we wanted light weight due to arm injury and it ended up being the same as what I already had ..heavy so it was still in original packing and I had not used so I took back for a rear… Read more
exchange to light weight..they said we DON'T give refunds and we DON'T exchange so choose carefully as your stuck with it..will never ever use this store agian
Follow-up · Have not been here since and refuse to buy anything here
Good Morning, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more
I recently ordered some consumables that needed to be back ordered. Before taking possession, I attempted to cancel the order. I was told that as this was a special order (not true, it is a normal stocked item) they would give me a store credit (not a cash refund) less a restocking fee. I was told that the restocking fee would be about 15%. I… Read more
wasn't very happy. However, I was even less impressed when the restocking fee was calculated at a whopping 32%. Then returned to the store to spend my store credit to see that the product that I had ordered was indeed in stock. To be fair the returns policy is clearly displayed in the store. However, it is an appallingly one-sided policy that basically states that no returns are accepted. The chaps in the store, including the store manager, are powerless to show any discretion. I won't be shopping at Sydney Tools ever again.
Good Morning, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more (+7 replies)
Sydney Tools, Archerfield QLD I had a frustrating experience with Sydney Tools regarding a nail gun service. I brought my gun in for inspection on 02 March 2026 and paid AU$35. I declined the full service costing around AU$311 and instead paid AU$132 for reassembly on 09 March 2026. When I picked it up, the tool was reassembled incorrectly,… Read more
with metal parts protruding, making it unsafe to use. I left it with them again, hoping it would be properly fixed.
In total, 23 days have passed, and I have already spent AU$167, yet the tool is still unusable. This has caused lost time, stress, and unnecessary expense, as I rely on my tools for work every day.
I hope Sydney Tools improves communication, quality control, and turnaround times for future customers. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this service at this time.
Good Morning, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more (+2 replies)
ProductReview.com.au has affiliate partnerships. These do not influence our content moderation policies in any way, though ProductReview.com.au may earn commissions for products/services purchased via affiliate links.
Good Afternoon, Thank you for your feedback. I… Read more